top of page

Subscribe Form

Thanks for submitting!

Search

RICHARD PREBBLE: Abolish the Tribunal, Preserve the Treaty

Sep 11
2 min read

ACT will complete the historical Treaty claims filed before 1 September 2008, end the Waitangi Tribunal’s contemporary jurisdiction, and wind it up once its historical work is finished, announced ACT Leader David Seymour.


I was a member of the Lange Government that extended the Tribunal’s jurisdiction back to 1840. Despite the difficulties that decision created, on balance I think it was the right decision.


We should be proud that New Zealand was founded not by conquest, but by treaty.


For a naval officer, it is a good statement of our founding principles.


The Crown — today, all of us — is sovereign. Property rights are protected. And the people of New Zealand enjoy the rights of British citizens: access to the courts and equality before the law.


I was later appointed to the Tribunal. I read its decisions and its strategic plan.


The Tribunal has reinterpreted the Treaty in ways that Hobson and the chiefs would not recognise. The Tribunal is heading towards constructing a radical new constitution, in which unaccountable iwi leaders would become permanent partners in the government of New Zealand.


I was not willing to lend my name to that project. I resigned.


I have given a great deal of thought to how the Tribunal might be reformed. It should always have been headed by a High Court judge.


I have come to the conclusion that David Seymour is right: the Tribunal is now unreformable.


That does not mean that Māori and non-Māori should lose the ability to hold the Government of the day to the Crown’s Treaty undertakings.


Here is my suggestion.


Abolish the Waitangi Tribunal. Make it clear that Parliament is sovereign, and that no Tribunal ruling which has not been accepted by the Crown is a legal precedent.


Preserve the right of any citizen to take a Treaty-related case to the High Court and seek a declaration as to whether the Crown has honoured its Treaty obligations.


That would preserve the Treaty as our founding document without allowing our constitution to be rewritten by a body that has no democratic mandate.


Richard Prebble is a former Minister and ACT Party leader. He writes at I've Been Thinking

 
 
 

72 Comments


Unknown member
Sep 13

ATM the tribunal appears to be the plaything of Caren Fox.....however did it come to this is the question to ask. We can only assume that the Public Service has not been accountable to Parliament and the people for too long. We have become a nation of "soft-cocks".

Like

Unknown member
Sep 13

Prebble does not get it, never has.

The Treaty was signed with Natives. Read it.

Natives needs to be defined.

The incoming Polynesian entered an inhabited country.

They attacked and murdered the indigenous.

Waitaha, Moriori, Patupaiarehe and others.

Remnants of those bloodlines can be found today.

The payouts are fraudulent and based upon fake history.

Seymour is an idiot shill for denying NZ's true history.

The sooner Seymour is driven from parliament the better.

Prebble never served any decent purpose.

The Natives asked for a Treaty.

I despair at the division in NZ.

Like
Unknown member
Sep 13
Replying to

WHY MAORI ACCEPTED THE TREATY

Europeans arrived here to find hundreds of small, disparate bands of subhuman cannibal savages existing in a Hobbesian state of nature with one another, in which “every man’s hand was against every other man’s,” "no man was secure in his life or in his property, “ and "life was nasty, brutish and short.”


Since some 512 chiefs signed the TOW and a substantial minority refused to, there were probably around 600 of these individually insignificant groups.


What is now New Zealand consisted of two main land masses and some offshore islands inhabited by numerous petty warring tribes “bearing few, if any political relations to one another; and who have proved incompetent to act, or even…


Like

Unknown member
Sep 12

As long as any court action is not paid repeat is not paid for by NewZealand Taxpayers for more of their B.S. Taniwha Taxes, extortion Koha, crippled New Zealand split and devided by Greedy corrupt IWI ,in Cahootswith GREEDY Corrupt Government MP'S and a very Corrupt Judicial System fleecing billions from NZ taxpayers. Winston Peter's and David Seymour Appear to be in agreeance on this matter. So Party VOTE NewZealand First and if excellent Candidates in your Electorate 2 x ticks, otherwise Party vote NewZealand First and if your Preferred has no candidate in your Electorate give Electorate vote to Act or National.

Like

Unknown member
Sep 12

The way the Treaty is presented and used it would seem there was only one side that was to obtain any benefit from it - Maori, with the other side - the Crown, shouldering all the duties and obligations. A totally lopsided an unrealistic arrangement, surely???


Like
Unknown member
Sep 13
Replying to

SOVEREIGNTY CEDED, PROPERTY AND CITIZENSHIP RIGHTS GUARANTEED FOR ALL

Article II of Te Tiriti grants “tino rangatiratanga” not just to brown supremacist part-Maori racists, but to ALL New Zealanders.


ARTICLE I of James Busby’s final English language draft dated 4 February 1840 and translated into Maori by the missionary Henry Williams and his son (both fluent Maori speakers who’d lived in NZ for almost 20 years) for presentation to the Chiefs on 5 February reads:


“The chiefs of the Confederation of the United Tribes AND THE CHIEFS WHO HAVE NOT JOINED THE CONFEDERATION [emphasis added] cede to the Queen of England for ever the entire Sovreignty [sic] of their country.”


That wipes out the ridiculous Declaration of Independence of the…


Like

Unknown member
Sep 12

With Maori politicians like Willie Jackson and every TPM MP loudly playing the broken record that Maori did not cede sovereignty, what chance do you think there is of your idea working? Despite ample evidence to the contrary, they continue with their mantra, and I'm sure many impressionable young Maori now believe it. They exhort us to honour the treaty, but by hypocritically denying the fact that they did cede sovereignty, they dishonour the treaty themselves. They demand more and more racial advantages in the name of honouring the treaty, and openly seek their own government, and a stranglehold on local government decision-making. The racist separatist movement is blatantly open and obvious, and extortion of vast sums of money fro…


Like
Unknown member
Sep 13
Replying to

KAWHARU’S RE-WRITTEN TREATY


In 1986, the Lange Labour Government commissioned Professor Sir Hugh Kawharu, Professor of Maori Studies at the University of Auckland, to produce a contemporary back translation of Te Tiriti’s Maori text.


Kawharu had just been appointed to the Waitangi Tribunal, a highly influential role he would hold for 10 years from 1986.


At the time of this appointment, Kawharu was also a claimant on behalf of Ngati Whatua, working on his tribe’s various Treaty claims, and representing it in the Bastion Point land claim negotiations.


Hardly someone without an axe to grind. Many might also recognise several conflicts of interest.


We might also ask why a further back-translation was needed, when TE Young’s 1869 back-translation compiled for…


Like

©2021 by Bassett, Brash & Hide. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page