SIMON O'CONNOR: Heads We Win, Tails It’s Illegitimate
Those on the left now accusing others of gaming the system want to change that system to suit themselves. The real problem is the idea that voters must vote a certain way.
There is a simple test of whether someone believes in democracy: do they still believe in it when they lose?
We do not yet have the final result from this election. The Electoral Commission will release the official count next Friday (27 November), once around 400,000 special votes are added in. Yet already a chorus has decided something has gone badly wrong. Not with their campaigns, their policies or their leaders, but with our electoral system itself.
Before I address these concerns, I think we should note a very key democratic principle: an election is legitimate not because it delivers the result you wanted, but because everyone agreed to the rules before a single vote was cast, and everyone accepts the outcome afterwards.
The words being used
Despite having agreed to the rules of the game, Chris Hipkins has called the election “manipulated” and Helen Clark called it “flawed”. Dame Anne Salmond went further, calling it “a travesty of an election campaign” and declaring that “the rules of MMP are being rorted, and Parliament is in danger of becoming a farce.”

Sir Geoffrey Palmer writes that the system has been gamed, that the result is “tainted by big money”, and that what has occurred is “constitutionally sad”. Of all the left-wing commentators on this, and they are pretty much all left-wing, Sir Geoffrey has been one of the very few to acknowledge both sides of this election have been “gaming” things.
Chlöe Swarbrick called it “a deeply cynical election”, accusing the government of having “knowingly indulge[d] in voter suppression.”
A dangerous narrative
A key point for me is that this is not harmless post-election grumbling. Confidence in our electoral system is slow to build and quick to spend. Every senior figure who tells New Zealanders the result was gamed, rorted, or flawed draws down on that confidence, and the bill is paid by all of us, whoever is in government.
Plus, the choice of words does matter.
These words and the wider narrative are also being amplified. Much of the commentary in our media and from the academy has leaned the same way. Now they are entitled to their views, but I cannot accept that there is unanimity on this matter. Instead, mainstream commentary is relying heavily on the views of those academics and commentators who are from the left.
They said they would accept the result
What makes all of this particularly striking is what was said before polling day.
Hipkins and Labour were clear they would respect the results and even emphasised this on election night itself.
And yet, just a few days later, he is out talking to media about how the election has been manipulated. He reminds me of Donald Trump’s various outbursts when he lost to Joe Biden back in 2020.
That does not mean Hipkins is Trump, or that “manipulated” is the same as “stolen”. It is not. But the instinct is the same: the result is not what they wanted, so the system must be at fault. Hipkins actually described that territory well before the election. He has now taken his first steps into it.
Splitting your vote is MMP
Underneath the language currently being used is a simple claim: that splitting votes was somehow illegitimate. It was not.
Under MMP you have two votes. That is not a fault or an irregularity. It is the design. People have split their votes since 1996 and will continue to do so. It’s what can happen when you give people two votes!
Yes, there were organised campaigns from both sides, including Te Pāti Māori and the likes of Reality Check Radio. It may be lost on some, but people are allowed to campaign. People are allowed to form groups, fundraise, and express their views. It’s called democracy.

Attempts by some within the commentariat to fixate on the identity of a few wealthy donors is simply an attempt to manipulate people’s jealously of others’ wealth, and direct that negative reaction onto the wider issue – that is, what they were promoting.
The paradox
Which brings me to the striking paradox currently at play. Those claiming the system has been manipulated now want to change it, and to change it in ways that would benefit them.
Clark wants a full review. Sir Geoffrey wants a Royal Commission. Others want an end to overhangs altogether. That does not mean MMP is beyond review; no system is. But it is hard to take seriously a complaint about others gaming the rules from people whose remedy is to rewrite them in their own favour, and whose concern appeared only once the numbers went against them.
That points to a wider pattern. Too often the left like democracy when they win and like science when it suits their agenda. The moment either stops working in their favour, they then claim the system is broken.
National, too, would do well to look at its own result rather than at the system.
At day’s end
The left did not win this election (or, more accurately, are unlikely to win it) for a simple reason: not enough people voted for them.
What Hipkins and others are really saying is that you have to vote a certain way. That your two votes should be used as they would like, for the candidates and parties they approve of, and that if you choose otherwise, the result does not count.
Now, that is what I would call illegitimate.
Simon O'Connor is a former National MP who writes at On Point
Another sore loser has shown up today and no surprise is saying pretty much the same things in the same way. They really should vary the script a bit more.
“Voters on the Māori roll have often split their votes to some extent, typically casting their electorate vote for New Zealand First or Te Pāti Māori, and their party vote typically for Labour.
In several elections that has resulted in an overhang of one or two seats.
But in the last election Te Pāti Māori made vote splitting a formal strategy and publicly advised they were not seeking the party vote.
That angered a few rich white men who responded with a tawdry and belated vote splitting strategy across all electorates.”
No Simon. MMP was "gamed" in this election. It may be legitimate but it is not in the spirit of true democracy. I would like to see a truly independent Royal Commission look at alternatives to MMP. Otherwise the voters will lose confidence in their democratic system altogether.
"the rules of MMP are being rorted, and Parliament is in danger of becoming a farce.”
No it's not, it already is since the time hats, haka's and foul language was allowed. However I digress, just suppose that the Special's did give the left block power, would it still be manipulated, flawed. a travesty and flawed.?
Geoffery can talk , he buggered up parliment by bringing in principals to the treaty and it has never been right since
without Maori seats the problem would be largely resolved.
If that was the first thing discussed and it was the MMP model proposed originally they may have some credibility.
But it's always a winge about the right.