RODNEY HIDE: Two votes is not a loophole
The Post ran two pieces on the election a day apart. Read together, they don't make sense.
Max Rashbrooke says voters should be "deeply disturbed". Big money, dark money and engineered overhangs, he says, may have swung the result. The government won not on argument but on cash and "cynically distorting the process".
The next day Andrea Vance mocked Harry Mowbray's campaign as a flop. The only thing it earned him, she wrote, was a police investigation. The right's overhang came from National's party vote collapsing, not from anyone being talked into splitting.
So which is it? Did money swing the election, or did it buy nothing? It can't be both. If Vance is right, Rashbrooke is alarmed about nothing. If Rashbrooke is right, Vance is laughing at the people who won.
Then there's the other side. Rashbrooke calls overhang engineering distasteful and an attack on MMP. He concedes the left got four overhang seats. Vance goes further. Te Pāti Māori, she writes, ran "a textbook overhang strategy", winning five seats on 0.57 per cent of the party vote, "and they didn't need a multimillionaire's chequebook to do it."
So splitting the vote is fine when the left does it with no money. It's a scandal when the right does it with some. That's not a principle. It's a preference about who wins.
But the bigger problem is the word "distorting". MMP gives every voter two votes. One for the local MP you want, one for the party you want. That's how it was sold in 1993. Voters can use each vote however they like. The overhang rule is written into the law on purpose.
A voter who ticks National's candidate and ACT's party is not distorting anything. They're using the system exactly as it was built. Nobody can buy that tick. The voter has to decide to do it, in the booth, on their own.
What both columns quietly assume is that the voters who split were duped. Money got to them. They didn't really mean it. That's an odd thing for defenders of MMP to believe. It sits uncomfortably close to Mowbray's own line about "emotional" voters, which Vance rightly mocks.
Rashbrooke even defends MMP against Mowbray in the same article. He wants the system kept. He just doesn't like what voters did with it.
The pieces trip over their own claims too. Rashbrooke says the effect of the enrolment cut-off is "impossible to measure precisely", then suggests it may have decided the election. He wants donations to parties capped, then admits that money would flow to the very outside groups he complains about. Vance says Mowbray converted nobody, then wants new laws to stop him.
The simple explanation is the one both writers skip. Voters were given two votes. Enough of them used both, the way the system invites them to, to get the government they wanted.
There was a campaign to explain overhang and the two votes -- just like I ran in Epsom in 2005. People weighed up that information along with everything else in the campaign and then voted. A great many more split their vote as a consequence.
That's not a loophole. That's MMP.
Rodney Hide is a former Minister and ACT Party leader
The strength of MMP is that it provides a way for voters to refine their broad preference for one of two potential coalitions. You give your electoral vote to the strongest candidate from the coalition you want to win & your party vote to that coalition’s natural partner with the policy platform you prefer. It’s a no-brainer!
If you extrapolate, on principle what the media are saying, in order to achieve a balanced election result, and not be guilty of political engineering, party members would be elected with 59% (71) of the members coming from electoral MP votes and 41% (49%) from party votes. And in observing "equity", that ratio should be uniform across the parties. Bollocks.
Andrea Vance says money is buying elections. Well, well, well. The media shamelessly promoted Opportunity. And they got 7 seats. Based on the balanced figures, should they not have 3 list party members and 4 electorate MPs seats?
Same with Greens. Should they not have 7 list party seats and 9 electorate seats?
So the Opportunity party which got shamelessly…
I will decide whether I am for or against the system when I know who won. If it is my team, I love it. Otherwise it is terrible.
I didn't get any money? I have always split my vote. Am I a mug?Show me the dough!
I was active in Peter Shirtcliffe's 'Campaign for a Better Government' and the overhang was recognised then as a potential problem. The Electoral Commision warned about it too in 2012. The MMP campaign was scornful of a recommendation from The Justice and Electoral Select Committee in favour of STV. It's taken us 30 years to recognise the pitfalls of MMP, maybe we'll shrug this unease off, but I'd rather we moved to STV - Aussie style.