top of page

Subscribe Form

Thanks for submitting!

Search

RODNEY HIDE - Luxon: Gone By Morning Tea

Oct 7
3 min read

Imagine the scene. Chris Luxon is speaking to a shed full of blokes in high-vis. He clears his throat, looks sincere, and announces that the future of world leadership is white and it's male.


The clip hits the internet before he’s out of the shed.


What would happen?


TVNZ would have a field day, and so would every newsroom north of Bluff. The Greens would issue a statement before Luxon had left the car park. Business NZ would discover a sudden interest in diversity. His caucus would start texting each other with names. By dinner he would be "reflecting", and by breakfast he would be reflecting from the back benches. Saying that out loud, on purpose, as a pitch for votes, would end a career.


Well, it did happen. Just not that way round.


In early August — weeks out from election day — Green co-leader Marama Davidson was at the National Iwi Chairs Forum in Queenstown. Chloe Swarbrick was beside her. The room was full of iwi leaders. The interviewer asked why Māori-roll voters should choose Green candidates in the Māori seats.


You might have expected housing. Or water. Or climate. Or anything that sounded like a reason to tick the Green box instead of the box for the Maori Party.


Davidson went another way:


"This is intentional. We know that the future of, not just Aotearoa, but worldwide leadership, is brown and it's wāhine."


Intentional. Worldwide. Brown. Women. As a vote pitch.


The crowd cheered. Chloe dared the room to disagree. There was laughter. Nobody walked it back. The party's own channels posted the session under the title “From Te Tiriti to Thirst Trap Baddies” [internet slang for an attractive, confident person—most often a woman—who posts intentionally alluring, sexy, or glamorous photos and videos on social media to capture attention, compliments, or romantic/sexual interest]. The clip has been doing the rounds again this week, because of course it has.


Swap the colours and the sexes and you have Luxon's men's-shed line — the one that would have ended him before the biscuits. Keep them as Davidson said them and you have a cheer line at a serious political forum, from a co-leader of a party that wants your party vote and seats at the cabinet table.


That is the gag, if you can call it one. The offence is not only the words. It is that the room treated them as wisdom. Race and sex as the job description. Preference sold as progress. Discrimination with a smile, a round of applause, and a dare to say no — which, funnily enough, nobody did.


The Greens are sitting around 14 to 16 percent in the polls. That is not a student flat. That is a party that could decide who gets the keys to the Beehive. And this is what one of its co-leaders offered as the case for the Māori seats: not merit, not ideas, not results — brown and female, on purpose, worldwide.


If Luxon had said the mirror image, the country would have known what to call it. When Davidson says it, and the crowd cheers, we are told it is leadership.


Racism and sexism have not gone away. They have just learned which way to point.


Rodney Hide is a former Minister and ACT Party leader

 
 
 

49 Comments


Unknown member
Oct 09

I noted that Luxon commented that the "Treaty" was our founding document on a panel discussion with London based Kiwi's. Obviously there will be no walking back on Maori aspirations should he become PM after the election.

Like

Unknown member
Oct 08

Shouldn’t count chickens, as the saying goes.

But I do remember, waiting for a ferry at midnight in Wellington, the radio news going on at the time about the price of eggs, in the days leading up to the departure of Dear Leader. NZ equivalent of Honecker took over from Ulbricht.

The sacred geese of Rome were thought to be portents, why not chickens for our mighty seat of power.

Like

Unknown member
Oct 08

If and when the Left loses the election coming, I’m looking forward to insane ravings as to cause.


The Brazilian Left ( or the insane far left part of that, can’t say what proportion) are baying at the moon over CIA/evangelists and begging the CCP for support and weapons. And they weren’t that far behind the other side. Comrade Helen was wishing President Lula ( who lost) many fraternal Marxist good wishes before the surprise ( to them) result.


The Far Left hates the not as far as them Left, in any polity, more than their supposed not left enemies. The yelling and insane talk is this going on.


Unless Hipkins and Luxon do a German style ‘Grand Coalition’ of…


Like

Unknown member
Oct 08

I listen to no one wanting elected power who has not had and raised a child.


Someone who has known despair is better often, than big talkers. Lange was both, but almost none since him have that ballast. Didn’t prevent him from being wrong, either.


Davidson and Swarbrick would do very poorly with any power. Their ideas are bad and their judgement is questionable. Therefore they appeal to the oppositional defiant characters, and those who live in their own heads exclusively, who have the vote.


But, if enough of those push Greens up as Labour sinks down, the grip of the present Top Ones in Labour might snap. That would be fun. A Labour Party bun fight like 1987-88 wa…


Like

Unknown member
Oct 08

Many things can be said, when electricity flows, today was like almost all days before in one life, and the very thin crust of civilization seems to go on.

Stupid uncorrected means those conditions fray.


Like

©2021 by Bassett, Brash & Hide. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page