RODNEY HIDE: Labour's route to power is all uphill
Last week I wrote that I couldn't see what Labour could do about 2029. So I had the numbers run.
Start with the board. Say National again wins 42 electorates, and that more National voters split their vote, say another 225,000. ACT and New Zealand First then take 15 per cent of the party vote each, assuming an even split. On that model the House grows to 142 seats. National's overhang jumps from 7 to 18. The right has 78 seats. It needs 72. That is a majority of six, not one.
That is Labour's hole. There are four ways out.
Route one: win the voters back.
Persuade right voters to vote Labour or Green. The trouble is how much it takes. While National holds its 42 electorates, every point Labour wins off the right mostly comes out of ACT and New Zealand First list seats. National's seats don't move. Its overhang just grows and the House gets bigger.
On the model, Labour, the Greens and Te Pāti Māori, with Opportunity, need a swing of about 7 points from the right to get a majority. That is some 175,000 people who voted National, ACT or New Zealand First switching to Labour or the Greens. On their own, without Opportunity, they need about 15 points. That is 365,000 people.
How big is that? Since 1999 the median change in the National, ACT and New Zealand First vote from one election to the next is about 5 to 6 points, or 120,000 to 145,000 voters. So 7 points is a good election, not a miracle. Swings that size happened in 2008 and 2017. But 15 points is a landslide. Only 2020 and 2023 were that big. That was the Covid election, and then the kick back.
And 2026 is no comfort. National fell almost 9 points, about 215,000 voters on this year's turnout. The right as a whole fell less than 3 points, under 75,000. The voters didn't leave. They moved next door.
Route two: take electorates off National.
Every electorate Labour takes from National is one less overhang seat. That shrinks the House and the right's buffer at the same time.
The seats are there. On the preliminary count National won Wairarapa by 139 votes. Hamilton East by 456. Whangārei by 1,092. Nelson by 1,210. Takanini by 1,487. Kapiti by 2,077. Labour came second in every one of National's 42 seats.
But that assumption is generous to Labour. The 100,000 assumes voters who switch their party vote also dump their National MP. Split voters are used to doing the opposite: they move the party vote and keep the National electorate MP. If they keep the MP, Labour needs the full 175,000. The truth sits somewhere between, and Labour doesn't get to choose.
Labour's best tool is getting Green and Opportunity voters in those six seats to back its candidate. That means deals and stand downs. Parties hate them.
And, of course, the centre right will be likewise changing tactics in those seats.
National has seats it can win too. On the preliminary count it came second in Mt Roskill by 262 votes and in Hutt South by 889. Banks Peninsula, Wigram, Christchurch Central, Waitākere, Palmerston North and Auckland Central would all fall on a swing of less than 5 points. Add Taieri and Mt Albert and that is 10 Labour or Green seats.
That calls for a marginal seat campaign, a dozen seats including holding Wairarapa and Hamilton East, not a national one.
Labour has more seats on a knife edge, starting with Wairarapa on 139 votes, so this is not a one way street. But the arithmetic is not symmetrical. National is already 18 seats into overhang, so each extra electorate is an extra seat for the right while Labour simply fills from its list. Winning those 10 would take the right from 78 of 142 to 88 of 152. Labour's hole gets deeper.
Route three: play the same game.
The left has already played it once. Te Pāti Māori won five electorates on 0.57 per cent of the party vote, just 13,845 votes. That vote earns it one seat. The other four are overhang, and they sit on the left.
Could Labour do more? Labour holds 21 electorates. Its 29 per cent of the party vote, 710,000 votes, earns it 36 seats, so it gets no overhang at all until its party vote falls below about 17 per cent. To knock the right off its majority, Labour's party vote would have to fall to about 6 per cent. That is four in five Labour voters, some 560,000 people, giving their party vote to the Greens. Labour would have to tell its voters not to vote Labour. National never asked its voters to do that. Others did it for them.
Route four: change the rules.
Labour could promise to abolish the overhang. But a law change needs a majority in Parliament, and the right has it. National, ACT and New Zealand First have no reason to give it up. Labour could only change the rule after winning, and winning is the problem. In 2012 the Electoral Commission recommended scrapping overhang seats along with the one electorate rule. Labour's member's bill to adopt that review left the overhang out. In six years of government Labour sent it to another review, which reported after Labour lost office.
So where does that leave Labour?
Needing a good election plus a few lucky seats. Something like a 2008 sized swing, Wairarapa to Takanini falling its way, and Opportunity on side. That means persuading somewhere between 100,000 and 175,000 people who just voted for the right to change sides. That is possible. It is not likely.
These are preliminary figures. The official result on 27 November may still move Wairarapa. And nobody knows how many National voters will split in 2029.
But my question has an answer. Labour can't counter the strategy. It can only outvote it. And thanks to RCR’s split vote campaign, the bar for doing that is now a lot higher than it was.
Rodney Hide is a former Minister and ACT Party leader
And so it continues..... what Rodney quotes are not the statistics of a secure system. They are the statistics of a system under siege.
Came across the following on a USA site earlier this morning
Civilization is what happens when the emergent order and human nature converge into something self-sustaining and high-function.
…and its corollary:
When a society’s story becomes incompatible with human nature, the society must either:
abandon the story and find one that is once more convergent
or use ever escalating force to make people behave as though the false story were true.
Where is NZ...and or for that matter Australia positioned in the above scenario...?.
Bewildered and lost in the wilderness at malfunction junction....and the over woke…
What's the one electorate rule?
I believe your scenarios are unlikely to pan out. The MMP genie is out of the bottle and there is widespread concern. All parties recognise we need to reform MMP – and before the 2029 election. My personal opinion is that MMP is irretrievably broken and nothing less that a new Parliamentary system is required (??? the Swiss approach anyone)..
National haven't won this one yet. If they cock up the next three years like the last then Labour and their shonky partners won't have to do anything to win in 2029. More power to NZF and ACT and Luxon has to go.
Are all these extra MPs going to sit on Bar Stools at the back of the house ?