RICHARD PREBBLE: The Future Never Comes
New Zealand First’s big promise this election is a Future Fund.
The Future Fund looks like a recycled version of the Provincial Growth Fund, but this time on steroids.
The Provincial Growth Fund was to be a $3 billion fund for “regional development”. Regional development turned out to include refurbishing 347 marae.
It also included $52 million for the loss-making Whakatōhea mussel farm in Ōpōtiki.
The Auditor-General questioned the administration and evaluation of the fund and expressed doubt about whether taxpayers would get value for money.
This time the promise is not $3 billion but up to $100 billion for “infrastructure”.
Infrastructure is apparently whatever Peters says it is.
The first promised “infrastructure” investment is to buy BNZ and merge it with Kiwibank, How reducing the number of banks increases competition is yet to be explained.
BNZ has about $12.5 billion of tangible ordinary equity. ANZ’s purchase of Suncorp Bank was at about 1.3 times tangible book value. On that basis, BNZ is worth about $16 billion.
But NAB, which owns BNZ, does not want to sell. It could demand well over $20 billion.
With the Government running a deficit of around $11 billion, where is the $100 billion coming from?
Apparently from ACC, the Super Fund, borrowing by issuing government bonds and private investors.
Why would any investor, including ACC, that can obtain a share of BNZ by buying NAB shares, pay perhaps twice as much by investing via a fund run by politicians?
Why is New Zealand First not being laughed at?
Is it because the promise is so absurd that no one takes it seriously?
Or is it because we think Winston will be safely overseas?
But the media reports that in the next government Peters wants a domestic role.
We cannot afford to keep Winston Peters at home.
Richard Prebble is a former Minister and ACT Party leader who writes at I've Been Thinking
I can never understand why nzfirst get such traction when the gave us the problem labour government of the last 6 years
I am glad that Mr Prebble thinks along similar lines
Vote NZF to give Winston one final huge suck at the taxpayers teat. No doubt though he will fool enough voters that this time he really will abolish the Waitangi Tribunal and Maori seats, move Auckland's port, fix up the regions infrastructure - whatever.
Most commentators here recognise the folly of politicians making decisions when they have one eye on their chance at the next election. On this weeks podcast Leighton Smith with Rodney Hide made the comment the biggest problem we have is lack of courage. How true - look what can happen with a courageous leader the best example is Javier Milei in Argentina. He was elected at the same time as Luxon but the results are miles apart.
Much of this like a beat up on NZF and Winston. All political parties are flawed. Including ACT.
In the court system, financial issues are one thing, but killing is several levels above that and is always a criminal matter.
Winston not only acknowledged he was wrong over Covid, and did a 180° U turn on them. He turned up at the Wellington protest. He has supported groups such as Voice For Freedom who are tirelessly working to address a range of issues from Covid vaccines, Digital ID, etc
Winston has been hammering away as the climate change fraud.
He got NZ out the automatic WHO signup that states that during the next pandemic, WHO have total control over health…
"Buying BNZ" is simplistic.
I would suggest it be nationalised, and pay NAB the owners, say $15b. Then I would fold Kiwi Bank into it and offer 49% as an IPO on the stock exchange. Along the way I would offer about 20% of the combined staff redundancy and ask all those left on $200,000+ to reapply for their positions. The end result would be a lean bank owned by our Government and any New Zealander willing to invest, that would have enough capital to compete with the big boys.
At the very least profits would stay in NZ. It might also be prudent to separate any land/buildings the BNZ currently owns out of the mix.