top of page

Subscribe Form

Thanks for submitting!

Search

RICHARD PREBBLE: A grumpy old man

Oct 5
2 min read

I remember being 16 years old. Only my friend Jim Middleton, who went on to become the ABC’s chief political correspondent in Canberra, and I had any interest in politics.


At university among my fellow students, it was only the Vietnam War and the fear that we might be conscripted that generated interest in politics.


And me? I organised parliamentary campaigns before I was old enough to vote. At 18 I was responsible for a campaign budget large enough to buy a house. Mind you, houses were cheaper.


There was a campaign to reduce the voting age to 18. At the time, looking at my classmates, I was opposed.


Nothing I have seen then or since has changed my mind.


Through most of our history society thought 21 was the correct age.


When the voting age was 21 the state did not spend money trying to persuade electors to enrol. This year the taxpayer is spending $18.1 million on encouraging people to enrol. At the latest count 166,746 18- to 24-year-olds are yet to do so.


In contrast, 103.25% of the estimated eligible 70+ population is enrolled. (There are more of us than the Commission realised.)


Not only is Labour going to let 16-year-olds vote in local elections, but as a ratepayer I am going to lose my non-resident ratepayer vote.


The Supreme Court has ruled that not allowing 16-year-olds to vote is inconsistent with the Bill of Rights Act’s prohibition on age discrimination. On that logic, why not give 14-year-olds the vote?


Not only do the advocates not remember being 16, it seems to me they cannot have had any 16-year-old children.


My father had the view that only those who were not dependent on the state should vote. He thought that when he received National Super, that should disqualify him.


He had the quaint idea that those on the paying list, not those on the getting list, should decide.


As, according to IRD research, just 10 per cent of income taxpayers pay more in tax than they receive in transfers, it would be a small electorate.


I hope most of us think stealing is immoral. How is it moral for a 16-year-old who has never paid rates to be able to vote that a ratepayer like me should pay more in rates? And Labour intends to strip me of my ratepayer vote.


Revolutions have been fought over taxation without representation.


Democracy is the tyranny of the majority. But a tyranny of 16-year-olds?


Richard Prebble is a former Minister and ACT Party leader who writes at I've Been Thinking

 
 
 

50 Comments


Unknown member
Oct 06

Was there a referendum on lowering the voting age if not there should have been or have it listed on the voting papers would be more to the point than a 'palastine' vote which is nothing to do with elections.

Like

Unknown member
Oct 06

Why don't we just go straight to voting by proxy before birth and have done with it!

Like

Unknown member
Oct 05

The left leaning parties require immaturity, poverty, racial privilege, beneficiaries and borrowing $billions to gain votes to achieve reelection.

The right leaning parties provide +ve economy, business, manufacturing & employment, budgeting and paying off debt to get reelection.

Has Govt over the years created too many receivers and now not enough givers?

Like

Unknown member
Oct 05

The voting age should return to 21. While parliament struggle to define a man and a woman, they may as well redefine what an adult is and that should kick in at their 21st birthday!


The age of 18 was only put in place because that was the age of conscription, so are we going to conscript 16-year-olds at the next declaration of war? I think not!


Maybe I'm just getting old but very many young adults seem very childish to me these days! Maybe I'm just a grumpy old man too!

Like
Unknown member
Oct 05
Replying to

I can imagine some of the youngsters, raised playing murderous games, would make useful drone operators in a conflict. Practical duties - not so much.

Like

Unknown member
Oct 05

I personally think that the left do not want government. I think they want the power but not the responsibility hence the ludicrous promises being made, none of which wil be delivered because as we all know promises from the left are merely aspirational.


I think the greens, maori party and most of labour are quite happy in opposition. Lovely salaries, perks and the occasional overseas trip courtesy of Gerry and the taxpayers so what's not to like.


When Winston gave them the keys they were buggered and we saw it, well most of us did.


This election is no different. Minimal effort, zero real policies to benefit the country but just enough dickheads out there to get most o…


Like

©2021 by Bassett, Brash & Hide. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page