top of page

Subscribe Form

Thanks for submitting!

Search

DON BRASH: The Human Rights Commission's new Treaty booklet is "good faith"?

29 minutes ago
4 min read

The following is written In Don's capacity as Hobson's Pledge Trustee.


The Human Rights Commission has just put out a new booklet called Ā Tātou Kōrero: Enabling Te Tiriti Conversations. It starts with an appeal most of us would agree with: "Let's commit to an inclusive national conversation based in good faith and good quality information."


Then it drops good faith almost straight away. What follows is a string of bold claims, many of them simply false, presented as settled fact. It is the familiar activist story of Treaty grievance, with very little regard for history. There are even posters you can download that tell you Māori never ceded sovereignty, and that tikanga being part of our common law is long-standing and uncontroversial. Neither claim is settled. The first is wrong, and the second is hotly disputed.


AN ATTACK ON OUR DEMOCRACY, FUNDED BY YOU


By page three, the Commission is openly questioning our democratic institutions. It says early breaches of the Treaty have "rippled out over time" and that "today, the rules and systems that determine how we make decisions and the ways we live together as a country do not reflect the agreements in our founding document."


Read that again. A taxpayer-funded Crown entity is telling New Zealanders that the free, democratic and liberal society we have built together is not legitimate. It echoes the academic who recently described our constitutional arrangements as "unjust, illegitimate and illegal."


REWRITING WHAT THE TREATY SAYS


The Commission claims Māori did not cede sovereignty and that the Crown and iwi leaders were meant to be equal partners. That claim goes against the text of the Treaty itself. It goes against what the chiefs said at Waitangi, against what they said at the Kohimarama conference of 1860, and against what Māori leaders said in the decades that followed.


Nobody pretends our history is spotless. There were real breaches after 1840, and they have been acknowledged and settled. But there was a great deal of good too. As a nation formed, all New Zealanders gained schools, health care and the rule of law. Māori men got the vote in 1867, years before many European men did, and the first four Māori MPs entered Parliament in 1868. You won't find that story in the Commission's booklet.


"HUMAN RIGHTS" THAT DIVIDE PEOPLE BY RACE


The Commission calls the Treaty a perfect framework for human rights. The irony is hard to miss. The Treaty activism it promotes wants to divide New Zealanders by race, which is the opposite of what human rights should mean. Human rights belong to every person equally. They are not split into Māori rights and different rights for everyone else.


The Commission also says the Treaty is already central to our constitution but needs even greater status. As I wrote earlier this week: "How a brief document of a few hundred words from 1840 could override an entire modern, complex constitutional system is a mystery, unless you understand the end goal. Replacing parliamentary supremacy with vague Treaty interpretations would shift power away from voters and hand it to an unaccountable class of judges, academics, and tribal elites who would become the sole arbiters of what is allowed in New Zealand."


SCAREMONGERING ABOUT PARLIAMENT


The booklet suggests human rights in New Zealand are weak and under threat. It hints, none too subtly, that the real problem is a sovereign Parliament: elected MPs, answerable to voters, who might pass laws the Commission and its activist friends don't like. Yet there are 35 Māori MPs in the new Parliament. That's hard to square with a system that supposedly shuts Māori out.


The Commission also seems preoccupied with what the United Nations and other international bodies think of New Zealand. At Hobson's Pledge we care about what New Zealanders think. They have been clear: they want equality, fairness and one law for all.


LOOK AT THE FOOTNOTES


The booklet points readers to the radical Matike Mai agenda, which would divide New Zealand along racial lines. It doesn't name He Puapua, but that agenda is plainly in mind too.


The footnotes look like serious research at first glance. Look closer, and they point back to the same radical voices, including the Auckland University lecturer who calls our nation illegal, illegitimate and unjust, along with the work of Margaret Mutu and Moana Jackson. This isn't balanced information for a "good faith" conversation. It's one side of the argument, published under the name of a public body and paid for by your taxes.


ENOUGH IS ENOUGH


The Human Rights Commission has become a megaphone for a separatist agenda. Its work divides rather than unites, and it tears down rather than builds. Hard-working Kiwis should not be paying for an organisation that undermines the society they are part of.


It is time to close the Human Rights Commission and end this taxpayer-funded nonsense. If National, ACT and New Zealand First are returned to government, they must deal with the Commission once and for all. It stands in the way of our country moving forward together. Here at Hobson’s Pledge we will make sure this message is heard clearly by all three of these political parties.


WE NEED YOUR HELP


Nobody else will point this out. The Commission has a taxpayer budget, a communications team and a ready audience in the media. Hobson's Pledge has you. Every time a document like this appears, we read it, take it apart and make sure New Zealanders know what's being said in your name and with your money.


We can only keep doing that with your support. Please donate to Hobson's Pledge today so we can keep shining a light on this and standing up for equal citizenship and one law for all.

 
 
 

6 Comments


Unknown member
3 minutes ago

Now is the time to really drain the swamp.

Enough of this unadulterated bullshit.

What totally waste of taxpayer money.

Like

Unknown member
4 minutes ago

Thank you Don, for YET AGAIN expounding the ideas and arguments in this essay. Surely ONE DAY - S o o n - the parliament can wake up to the stupidity and fear that has been their over-riding weakness. We are ALL EQUAL CITIZENS..... Get it Labour, Nats, et al???? ...[all the new hangers on ! like Opportuniddy.. ] Maori Pardy needs to go.... Maori Roll needs to roll away.... This is getting .. B o r i n g...

Like

Unknown member
15 minutes ago

I have taken the liberty of FWD Don's message to the leaders of the former Coaltion and hopefully the next Government, with my message added.


"Dear Ministers: I forward this email from Don Brash at Hobson's Pledge and urge you to read this carefully.

 

It is very evident that the so-called Human Rights Commisson, which is funded by taxpayers lcompletely lacks credibility. It denies historical facts, works towards creating disunity among and between various ethnic groups who all are in fact New Zealanders, and blatantly supports future tribal rule in New Zealand against the wishes of more than 85% of the population.

 

Although the three of you represent the Coalition, it is evident that it is not possible…

Like

Unknown member
16 minutes ago

Utterly tired of all this nonsense taxpayers need to unite and say NO to paying taxes whilst this continues.

Like
Unknown member
12 minutes ago
Replying to

Excellent strategy.


Lord Normanby instructed Gov. Hobson ( in writing) to walk away unless the Treaty terms were fully agreed.

Like

©2021 by Bassett, Brash & Hide. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page